Is it wrong to charge exurbanite prices for food, fuel and
other necessities during a disaster?
If your answer is yes, please consider the following:
A man works hard 60
hours a week for minimum wage for seven years. During this time he never eats
out, goes to the movies or does anything fun, instead he invests every penny he
can into resources he imagines will be in high demand at some future point.
For years everyone calls this man crazy, a conspiracy theorist
and a quack. None the less the man stock piles waiting for the day that money
loses value and the demand for goods sky rockets. He is sure that sooner or
later there will be war, famine, the collapse of the dollar, or some kind of natural
disaster. He knows that when that day
comes he will have gambled several years of his life to hit the jack pot.
And then it happens, a massive hurricane, an earthquake, a
drought, you name it; the man’s gamble is about to pay off. Then the government shows up and demands the
man sell his massive stockpile at fair market value. The man agrees, “No
problem, I will sell it for 100 times what I paid and it will be gone in a
matter of hours.” “No the government says, you must sell it at roughly the same
price it is being sold elsewhere.” “But wait,” the man says, “that is not fair
market value that is an imposed value. I am not selling my goods at such a
price that prevents me from having an eager customer base, in fact only by
auctioning my goods off would I know what the current market value is.”
The government’s response, “It is not fair to sell your goods at such a price as to only allow the most wealthy to be able to afford necessities like food, fresh water etc.” “FAIR,” the man shouts, “FAIR! I gambled seven years of my life that a tragedy would take place where I would be able to take advantage of the rich allowing me to retire and live out the rest of my days in luxury. Now you are going to come in and force me to sell my life’s investment at or around cost? Then you will come back and demand taxes, you will fine me for not having a business license, and when it is all done and said, after attorney fees, fines and taxes, I will only have enough money to buy a bus pass and a suite to go and look for a job sense my place of employment was destroyed in the event. Why don’t you just confiscate my resources by executive order and give them away?” …
The government’s response, “It is not fair to sell your goods at such a price as to only allow the most wealthy to be able to afford necessities like food, fresh water etc.” “FAIR,” the man shouts, “FAIR! I gambled seven years of my life that a tragedy would take place where I would be able to take advantage of the rich allowing me to retire and live out the rest of my days in luxury. Now you are going to come in and force me to sell my life’s investment at or around cost? Then you will come back and demand taxes, you will fine me for not having a business license, and when it is all done and said, after attorney fees, fines and taxes, I will only have enough money to buy a bus pass and a suite to go and look for a job sense my place of employment was destroyed in the event. Why don’t you just confiscate my resources by executive order and give them away?” …
Comments
Post a Comment