Metrics and Methodology: The Failure in Determining the Justification for Public Policy

By Matthew Hayward

In the wake of a rare tragedy, it is not uncommon for policymakers to propose public policies with far-reaching implications for the general public. The goal is often to protect a small number of people from harm, whether from themselves, a criminal, or a crazed individual. However, the metrics and methodology used to justify such policies are often flawed, leading to unintended consequences and a loss of personal liberties.

One of the main issues with using rare tragedies to justify public policy is that they are statistically insignificant. For example, in the United States, mass shootings make up a tiny fraction of all gun deaths. Yet, they receive disproportionate attention in the media and from policymakers. This leads to a skewed perception of the danger posed by guns and a rush to pass laws that may not be effective in addressing the underlying issues.

Furthermore, even when rare tragedies occur, it is often difficult to determine the root cause of the problem. For example, after a school shooting, policymakers may propose stricter gun control laws, but this ignores other potential contributing factors such as mental health issues, bullying, or a lack of resources for troubled youth. Without a comprehensive understanding of the problem, developing effective policies that address the underlying issues is impossible.

Another issue with using rare tragedies to justify public policy is that it can lead to a loss of personal liberties. For example, after the 9/11 attacks, the US government passed the Patriot Act, granting the broad government powers to surveil its citizens. While this law was intended to prevent future terrorist attacks, it has also been used to infringe on the privacy rights of law-abiding citizens.

In order to develop effective public policies that do not infringe on personal liberties, policymakers must use sound metrics and methodology to determine the root causes of problems and develop evidence-based solutions. This requires a comprehensive understanding of the issue and a willingness to consider all contributing factors.

Policymakers must be willing to engage in open and honest dialogue with the public to ensure that any proposed policies are in line with public values and beliefs. This includes soliciting feedback from all stakeholders, including those who may be directly impacted by the proposed policy.

The use of rare tragedies to justify public policy is often fraught with issues stemming from flawed metrics and methodology. To develop effective policies that do not infringe on personal liberties, policymakers must use sound metrics and methodology to determine the root causes of problems and develop evidence-based solutions. They must also engage in open and honest dialogue with the public to ensure that any proposed policies are in line with public values and beliefs. Only then can we ensure that public policies are effective, just, and equitable for all.

When Government Demands Papers We Refuse

By Matthew Hayward 9/19/2025 The Supreme Court just paused a lower court order that had limited federal immigration stops in Los Angeles. That stay lets federal agents resume roving patrols and interior operations that critics say rely on appearance, language, job, or neighborhood to pick people for questioning. This matters because it normalizes a posture of suspicion. Checkpoints miles inland and roving patrols turn movement inside the country into a condition to be earned rather than a freedom to be enjoyed. The government already claims expanded authority inside the 100-mile border zone. That claim, plus an open green light for stops based on appearance, is a recipe for arbitrary enforcement. Philosophy of resistance John Locke told us that the consent of the governed is the foundation of legitimate power. When rulers invade life, liberty, or property, or when they become arbitrary disposers of people’s lives and fortunes, the social compact is dissolve...

The National Guard Was Never Meant to Be a Federal Tool

By Matthew Hayward 7/13/2025 Let me say this clearly: the National Guard was created to defend the states, not to enforce the will of the federal government. It was meant to serve as a local militia—an armed extension of the people under the control of the state. The highest authority a Guard member was ever supposed to answer to is their elected governor, not a bureaucrat in Washington, not a federal agency, and certainly not a sitting president weaponizing military force on domestic soil. Yes, I know the laws have changed. I know the Montgomery Amendment, the National Defense Act, and the Supreme Court's decision in Perpich v. DoD rewrote the rules. But legal doesn’t mean constitutional. Gradualism doesn’t legitimize usurpation. You don’t get to trample foundational principles and call it progress. What’s happening now—federalizing state forces to deploy them in cities without gubernatorial consent—is blasphemous. It's an insult to the very spirit of the Constitution. The ...

Reality Is Rigged and You Can Hack It

By Matthew Hayward 7/29/2025 Manifesting Reality: How the Matrix, Quantum Entanglement, and Consciousness Intertwine Look, science fiction and science fact have been flirting for decades. But lately, the line between the two is starting to disappear. The idea that we’re living in a simulated reality isn’t just a late-night stoner theory anymore. It’s a framework, a lens to view those weird, unexplained moments that leave you thinking, "What the hell just happened?" Quantum entanglement, synchronicity, manifestation… they all start to make a lot more sense when you stop pretending reality is some rigid, mechanical machine. It’s not. It’s code. And if you’re paying attention, you might just figure out how to rewrite it. NPCs vs Manifestors: Who’s Really Running Things? Picture the world like a massive open-world video game. Some people are just running the default programming. They go to work, follow the script, consume what they’re told, and never ask questions. NPCs. Then the...

Search This Blog